Actions need to start speaking louder than words

NATHAN’S not that kind of player. Neither is Callum and nor is Ryan.

We’ve heard the football manager’s stock excuse for reckless tackles a lot of late.

When will bosses and the FA, in this case the FA of Wales, wake up to what is becoming a growing and worrying problem?

Glenn Howes is 29 years old and was quickly reaching his prime in the semi-pro game.

Who knows how far he could have gone, possibly with promotion-chasing Poole Town?

He will never know because of a split-second in Merthyr.

Nathan Davies received a three-match ban for a tackle which, on video, looked reckless at best and downright disgraceful at worst.

Glenn Howes will never play football again.

Tommy Elphick was lucky and everyone in the game who deplores these kind of heedless tackles is hoping Newcastle’s Massadio Haidara receives the same good fortune as the Cherries defender as he begins his recovery. His prognosis looks good, thankfully.

The same cannot be said for Howes. Ruptured medial and posterior cruciate ligaments, damaged cartilage and a fractured knee joint were simply too much to come back from.

But, remember, Nathan is not that kind of player.

That may be so. But this is about more than being unable to play the beautiful game. From grassroots right up to the top level of the professional ranks, it is about the livelihoods of players who are victims of horrendous tackles like the ones from Nathan Davies, MK Dons’ Ryan Lowe and Wigan Athletic’s Callum McManaman in recent months.

Regardless of intent or pre-meditation, the punishment should fit the crime. Unfortunately, in football, it rarely does.

It is very easy to say “I didn’t mean it”. It should be just as easy for the FA to respond by throwing the book at them anyway.

Comments(9)

Mike Oxbig says...
7:28am Sat 23 Mar 13

A level standard artice Meldrum, you scummer.

work12 says...
8:37am Sat 23 Mar 13

Mike Oxbig wrote:
A level standard artice Meldrum, you scummer.
Your comment is a bit strong. Whilst the comment in your view may be ''A level standard article'', this is Meldrums view.

Alomost on a daily basis people have used this site as a lets just slag and put my views across regardless of the situation or story. I do agree that some of the storys on here are somewhat over explained or pointless stories but it does annoy me when people start getting personal.

djd says...
8:49am Sat 23 Mar 13

I think Neil Meldrum is right. The players of today are taught to play like this and to tackle as close as they dare to the limit of the rules.
What happens hen that tackle goes slightly wrong, as it does?
We see the results in Elphick,Howe and others who have their careers at least halted if not ended.
My concern is that this is how the youngsters of today are also being taught, that a punch in the kidneys, a knee in the groin are acceptable in the game.
The FA need to curb this behaviour from the top clubs down and hopefully the message will filter through, crude violence will not be tolerated in the game.

PragueCherry says...
9:07am Sat 23 Mar 13

Mike Oxbig wrote:
A level standard artice Meldrum, you scummer.
You're entitled to your opinion of course, however I think Neil's comments are something that many who play/played football at some level have been talking about. I like a news article that is relevant and offering a non-sensational opinion.

Also, your 'Scummer' remark is worthy of a five year old.

mark.s says...
10:37am Sat 23 Mar 13

Fair article and good points made from Meldrum. We know how massive an impact Elphick's injury had on us. Losing 5 games at the worst time of the season, being without our best defender as a massive factor in that. Injuries happen, but serious tackles were there seems to be intent are not 'one of those things' that we might expect from football.

As for Meldrum being a 'scummer' - meh, we may well be playing that lot again in the not too distant future. He writes fairly, who cares.

slepe12 says...
5:13pm Sat 23 Mar 13

Glen Howes can no longer play at all. Typical Cherries supporters they think they are the only ones on the planet, the two cases are entirely different. Glen is being forced to finish playing prematurely, and without the knowledge of his income being guaranteed.

jakeysredd says...
9:35pm Sat 23 Mar 13

slepe12 wrote:
Glen Howes can no longer play at all. Typical Cherries supporters they think they are the only ones on the planet, the two cases are entirely different. Glen is being forced to finish playing prematurely, and without the knowledge of his income being guaranteed.
What are you on about Cherries fans for we are talking about ridiculous tackles that go unpunished that finish players careers, im sure Glen Howes will have some insurance to at least help him through loss of earnings due to sporting injuries, if not then he has been ill advised by his club Poole Town, A lot of Cherries fans are just as appalled by these tackles as you the one man and his dog Poole Town fan its the thugs of the game like the Merthyr man you should be venting off at cheers,

Ashleyafcb says...
2:54pm Sun 24 Mar 13

jakeysredd wrote:
slepe12 wrote:
Glen Howes can no longer play at all. Typical Cherries supporters they think they are the only ones on the planet, the two cases are entirely different. Glen is being forced to finish playing prematurely, and without the knowledge of his income being guaranteed.
What are you on about Cherries fans for we are talking about ridiculous tackles that go unpunished that finish players careers, im sure Glen Howes will have some insurance to at least help him through loss of earnings due to sporting injuries, if not then he has been ill advised by his club Poole Town, A lot of Cherries fans are just as appalled by these tackles as you the one man and his dog Poole Town fan its the thugs of the game like the Merthyr man you should be venting off at cheers,
I don't see what you have against Bournemouth mr play on a field we keep you alive if it wasnt for us looking at Austin in the 1st place you wouldnt have got the money you did one !! 2 your biggest crowd is when you play us !! I for one am fed up of some of your fans on twitter thinking your some sort of sunday league rival i wont be attending no more il go watch wimborne

poole_born says...
10:15am Wed 27 Mar 13

Ashleyafcb wrote:
jakeysredd wrote:
slepe12 wrote:
Glen Howes can no longer play at all. Typical Cherries supporters they think they are the only ones on the planet, the two cases are entirely different. Glen is being forced to finish playing prematurely, and without the knowledge of his income being guaranteed.
What are you on about Cherries fans for we are talking about ridiculous tackles that go unpunished that finish players careers, im sure Glen Howes will have some insurance to at least help him through loss of earnings due to sporting injuries, if not then he has been ill advised by his club Poole Town, A lot of Cherries fans are just as appalled by these tackles as you the one man and his dog Poole Town fan its the thugs of the game like the Merthyr man you should be venting off at cheers,
I don't see what you have against Bournemouth mr play on a field we keep you alive if it wasnt for us looking at Austin in the 1st place you wouldnt have got the money you did one !! 2 your biggest crowd is when you play us !! I for one am fed up of some of your fans on twitter thinking your some sort of sunday league rival i wont be attending no more il go watch wimborne
Ha - you're a joke. You keep Poole Town alive?? I'd suggest only one of those clubs is run like a proper business where the balance sheet is in the black.............
And as for Austin - luckily for him, his career wasn't held back by joining Cherries. And why was that? Oh yes, transfer embargo because of the awful way the Club is run.
Yeah - his career really suffered by not going to Bournemouth.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree