Couple who stole relative's home "to pay for her care" spared jail

Michael White at Bournemouth Crown Court Michael White at Bournemouth Crown Court

A COUPLE who sold an elderly relative’s house after she became ill have been spared jail.

A charity boss has warned the elderly to ensure they can trust friends or relatives before appointing them to manage their financial affairs.

Jane White, 57, and her husband Michael White, 61, from Berkley Road, Pimperne, were found guilty of stealing £54,722 from Mrs White’s aunt, Olive Cutler, between June 1, 2006 and January 31, 2011, after she became too ill to look after her own interests.

Age UK Bournemouth’s chief officer David Leighton said: “Exploitation of vulnerable people is shocking but, thankfully, this is an isolated case. It will make people frightened to give power of attorney but it is important that they don’t leave it too late as it can cause dreadful problems.

“I would encourage people to be careful; it shouldn’t be done on a whim. They have to have complete faith and trust that the individuals involved have their best interests at heart. Where money is involved there is always a risk.”

Bournemouth Crown Court heard how widowed Mrs Cutler, who is in her late 80s and suffers from Alzhemier’s, lives at a North Dorset care home.

Prosecutor Carolyn Branford-Wood said the vulnerable pensioner had moved in with the Whites in early 2003. She added: “The following year Mr White was given power of attorney. After spending a few weeks in hospital in 2006 Mrs Cutler moved into a residential care home.”

Ms Branford-Wood said the first 12 weeks of Mrs Cutler’s care had been funded by Dorset County Council, adding: “Later that year her property was sold and funds from that sale were put into an account and used to pay the care home fees.”

An investigation was launched after Mr White applied to the council for financial assistance for Mrs Cutler in 2010. Mrs Cutler’s mental health has deteriorated so much she could not give evidence and is unaware her home has been sold.

Defending, Brian Sharman said: “The defendants feel that their aunt would not have minded what they did; that money is ironically money which would have gone to Mrs White – we have a copy of the will.”

He added: “In my career I have never been given a petition with so many signatures from villagers who regard this couple as of tremendous social value.”

Mr Sharman described Mrs White’s health as “in an extremely grave state” adding that she relied on her husband to care for her and her elderly parents.

Judge Samuel Wiggs said: “This was undoubtedly a high degree of a breach of trust but I do not think it is in the public interest to send either of you immediately to prison.”

He added that Mrs White’s health would make it “extremely difficult” for her to cope behind bars and said he was also taking into account their “exemplary character.”

Mr White was handed a 12-month prison sentence, suspended for two years, and ordered to carry out 200 hours of unpaid work. Mrs White was given a nine-month prison sentence, suspended for two years.

There were gasps of relief in the packed public gallery. The Whites, who were found guilty of theft, could have been jailed for up to six years.

Comments(7)

HRH of Boscombe says...
2:35pm Tue 2 Oct 12

I wonder if the courts would be as lenient if they stole that amount from the tax man?

pete woodley says...
5:07pm Tue 2 Oct 12

The couple were devious and should have been sent down,obviously have the right(wrong) connections.

l'anglais says...
9:31pm Tue 2 Oct 12

Who would have paid for her care if the proceeds of the property had not done so?
Surely unearned property assets should be placed into trust at pension retirement age. Then used as a matter of priority to look after the aging population, especially when they become too ill to care for themselves.
99% of pensioners have not earned the value of their properties, so release your capital to boost the economy and increase the housing stock you old gits.

billd766 says...
3:48am Wed 3 Oct 12

l'anglais wrote:
Who would have paid for her care if the proceeds of the property had not done so?
Surely unearned property assets should be placed into trust at pension retirement age. Then used as a matter of priority to look after the aging population, especially when they become too ill to care for themselves.
99% of pensioners have not earned the value of their properties, so release your capital to boost the economy and increase the housing stock you old gits.
Why should pensioners who have worked all their lives, bought their own house and saved be forced to sell up because YOU say so.
They have earned their retirement and what comforts they have.
From your posts that I have read you seem to me a miserable person and jealous of anybody YOU think has more than yourself.
EVERYBODY who is buying their own property is in the same position because house prices keep rising, not just older people.

MandinVerwood says...
8:06am Wed 3 Oct 12

Perhaps it's me, but I think that these people have tried to do the best that they can. What would Age UK like these people to do for her Aunt, leave her to her own way?

If they had not taken the decision to sell and use the money for the Aunts care, then they would have been better off financially. It is a commitment to look after the interests of elderly relatives and nowhere can I see it was done for their own greed. They say this case was a one-off, now I doubt that very much.

As for the people asking them to be jailed, what do you think should have happened? should you put the hand in your own pocket if the finances aren't there to give a relative that you care about the life that they want?

Mr N James says...
8:38am Wed 3 Oct 12

It always the people that show good on the out side turne out be rotten to the core.

Was Charlie says...
9:19am Wed 3 Oct 12

l'anglais wrote:
Who would have paid for her care if the proceeds of the property had not done so?
Surely unearned property assets should be placed into trust at pension retirement age. Then used as a matter of priority to look after the aging population, especially when they become too ill to care for themselves.
99% of pensioners have not earned the value of their properties, so release your capital to boost the economy and increase the housing stock you old gits.
If you'd been following this story, when the money from the sale of her house was gone they asked the council for assistance in paying for the care home.
....
How are assets from property unearned? Property bought long ago was just as expensive as it is now. Even costing a bit over £3,000, our first house meant we had to go without holidays, car, TV, washing machine, etc and have just a little secondhand furniture because of pay levels at the time.
.....
The fact that house prices have risen is irrelevant. If you want to move, the proceeds from one house goes to buy the next. Paying interest on the mortgage means you pay at least twice the price you agreed on purchase. Property assets are well and truly earned.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree