Fury as MP tells teachers: don't strike, you're lucky you have a job (From Thisisdorset)
When news happens send us your pictures, video and views. Text BE to 80360 or contact us by email
Fury as MP tells teachers: don't strike, you're lucky you have a job
12:44pm Thursday 21st March 2013 in Latest
Fury as MP tells teachers: don't strike, you're lucky you have a job
TEACHERS threatening to strike in the New Forest have reacted with fury after an MP told them they were lucky to have their jobs.
Responding to a union letter outlining reasons for a planned strike by teachers Desmond Swayne told them they should remember that times were hard.
“You have a job and many don’t,” he said.
The letter was written by the National Union of Teachers and distributed to members and to colleagues in other unions.
Tom Roberts, a teacher at Priestlands School in Lymington for ten years, sent it on to Mr Swayne, New Forest West MP and former Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Prime Minister, to draw his attention to the feeling among teachers.
He said he was shocked by the MP’s blunt reply.
Mr Roberts, 60, said: “I just could not believe his response. He was basically saying that we don’t matter.
“I emailed him back to ask him whether this was really what he meant to say to the people who voted him in.
“I don’t think that someone in his position should be talking to people like this and I would suggest he reviews what he has said.”
Mr Swayne goes on in his rebuke to suggest that by adopting the values of “the shop floor” teachers were undermining their profession.
That view was criticised by union leaders who described the MP’s comments as “bonkers”.
But last night Mr Swayne, who was a teacher for seven years, stood by his comments.
He said: “I gave a robust response to a standard union letter which is what people can expect. It would be different if I was sent a personal handwritten letter from a constituent.
“Teachers do have relatively secure jobs and well paid jobs along with a good pension that many people do not have.
“I don’t believe that they can call themselves a profession while at the same time taking strike action.”
The two largest unions, the NUT and the NASUWT, have threatened strike action with a rolling programme of walkouts beginning at the end of June.
They have called on Education Secretary Michael Gove to engage in negotiations and discuss their concerns over pensions and the introduction of performance related pay.
Comments(120)
Edna Cheese (Mrs)
says...
1:02pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Pablo23
says...
1:08pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Tig
says...
1:14pm Thu 21 Mar 13
.
"Mr Roberts, 60, said: “I just could not believe his response. He was basically saying that we don’t matter." No he wasn't saying that, not at all.
.
I get fed up with (some) teachers moaning about how hard done by they are, when they get decent pay and school holidays off (and they're not spending the whole time preparing and marking), whilst the rest of us have to work all year round.
.
Teachers are not the only ones who work hard, but the bottom line is that they ARE lucky to have jobs in this time of recession. Keep your heads down and get on with it, like most working people have to.
logic subroutine
says...
1:19pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Teachers are not special. We all contribute to the sum total of the countries future. Do your job like the rest of us.
I worry about the children being taught by people with such a skewed view of reality...
scrumpyjack
says...
1:19pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Edna Cheese (Mrs) wrote:I believe they have chosen June. Spooky.
Hear Hear. Well done Desmond. They should be ashamed if they go on strike. Probably summer term. Monday or Friday.
speedy231278
says...
1:23pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason
says...
1:36pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
goatty
says...
1:42pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
muscliffman
says...
1:42pm Thu 21 Mar 13
It must be hard though being in a virtually unsackable job for about 38 weeks a year but on a full 52 weeks annual pay followed by a lifetime pension - all funded by the public.
Nice work if you can get it! Be grateful and count your blessings teachers.
Rodney Trotter
says...
1:54pm Thu 21 Mar 13
goatty wrote:I think you will find most decent hard working people but in far more hours and work in to their jobs than you think, teachers do not have the monopoly. You don’t see or hear of these people morning or going on strike, they are just happy to have a job, and do what’s needed to keep it. It’s about time an MP with balls to say what needs to be said.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Herbert Austin
says...
1:58pm Thu 21 Mar 13
logic subroutine wrote:Those who do not move do not notice their chains. Luxemberg.
Could not agree more. I've not had a pay rise for 6 years now, times have been tough where I work, but I am grateful that my MD has kept things going and we all still have a job!
Teachers are not special. We all contribute to the sum total of the countries future. Do your job like the rest of us.
I worry about the children being taught by people with such a skewed view of reality...
pauls55
says...
2:07pm Thu 21 Mar 13
delta3
says...
2:16pm Thu 21 Mar 13
2:07pm Thu 21 Mar 13
I'd like to see how the usual moaners here who really believe all the stereotypes fed to them by right wing rags like the Daily Mail on Teachers and their so called life of luxury would manage facing a class room of children every morning, bet you lot wouldn't last five minutes. Teachers do one of the most valuable jobs possible and deserve respect not the usual trite comments seen here.
Agreed SOME teachers are very good while the rotten apples hide away still reaping the benefits of being a respected member of society. I know of a teacher that failed placements but got a job because the placements would not give a negative reference and she was fast tracked as she had a poor degree and couldn't find work in her chosen field. As for hours, I work plus 50 a week, am on call and never have a day off without disturbance but as i work in the Private sector I need to produce results or I will be replaced. Kids are the only group that striking hurts so work your excuses hold no weight with me.
jmd4eva
says...
2:18pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Ps, Echo, you "conveniently" forgot to clarify that Mr Swayne is a Tory MP in the article... you're such a bunch of suck ups.
logic subroutine
says...
2:26pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Oh I notice it!. That's why I freelance to make up the difference and in the process of starting my own business.
But what's the point of striking and disrupting something that will be destroyed by those actions? I view such actions as selfish and short sighted. Also simply dropping Marxist quotes does nothing to contribute, especially when you don't know the full picture. How about speaking in your own words?
sea poole
says...
2:29pm Thu 21 Mar 13
cherrydragon
says...
2:39pm Thu 21 Mar 13
They do work hard yes, but the MP I am afraid is right.
I get paid to work 40 hours a week. I am in sales so sometimes I have to stay away, which I am not paid for...but guess what, the company pays for my transport (same as teachers) pay for my accomodation (same as the teacher) and pay for my meals (oh same as teachers).
Some weeks I must work 60 hours to get deals over the line and if we lose it, I do not get anything....it is called life...it is called work. If you do not like your job get another one / talk to your boss like we ALL have to do.
Why is public sector so shielded from the reality of it? They would not last 5 minutes as an IT Trainer or a travelling coporate teacher teaching people software etc....I do not understand it.
Come on teachers do us all a favour and wake up and smell the coffee, we are work really hard - deal with it!
cherrydragon
says...
2:42pm Thu 21 Mar 13
sea poole wrote:But is striking the answer? If a child in a teacher's class refuses to work, do they get such treatment? ?No, they get a detention and thrown out the class like when I was at school (yes I tried going on strike...it failed and fell on deaf ears) so why on Earth should teachers throw a tantrum, strike, and cause such disruption? Where is the difference?
Interesting that most comments talk about security of the teaching profession- there's a considerable number of redundancies being made within the profession, based on shrinking school budgets...and for those of you who are envious of the 'long holidays' and relatively short 'working week' why not swallow your envy and join the ranks of the profession- it's obviously causing you so much jealousy...
Bohochic72
says...
2:46pm Thu 21 Mar 13
afcb-loyal
says...
2:47pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Winton and Glenmoor have slowly gone downhill over the last 10 years promising this and that every time there is a parent evening and in reality it just gets worse.
The kids are in charge not the teachers.
Half are too young for the job and lack experience and are frightened of the kids.
Before all you teacher defenders come on here moaning about my post its true i have had to put up with sh1te teaching for the five years they been there with no change.
Training days, holidays, snow, live in the real world for gods sake.
There are a couple of "old school" teachers there that do not fall in the above category.
cherrydragon
says...
2:52pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Bohochic72 wrote:Yes I have - I would like to bring out the fact that Teaching Children (who mostly do not want to be taught) is very different and more difficult than teaching paying clients (who pay you to teach them so they want to learn to get their money's worth)
Having worked as a teacher for the last twenty years, I still find it astonishing that we're apparently allowed the same number of weeks off that our students have. I could start on the posters but, have you actually tried teaching someone?
It is a different game and no one is saying you get ALL that time off but let's face it, it does not take 6 weeks in the summer to plan for classes, not with modern technology and an already written syllabus...surely not.
High Treason
says...
2:54pm Thu 21 Mar 13
goatty wrote:I wonder how many of you would cope with a school trip to The Somme, not once but every year, time after time. The pupils learn the facts at school but try coping with dozens of pupils weeping at the reality of it all. Probably the first time in their lives they realise how others suffered to keep this country free. Row upon row of graves, the quietness and sense of calm. No parents there to console them, just their friends and teachers. Try keeping a watchful eye on them all, ensuring they are safe and supported in their visit. Maybe some of you should pay a visit to The Somme, it may just remove some of the bitterness and jealousy you have. You really haven't a clue.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
The Liberal
says...
2:55pm Thu 21 Mar 13
afcb-loyal
says...
2:59pm Thu 21 Mar 13
goatty
says...
3:04pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason wrote:never read such a load of nonsense and rubbish in my life
goatty wrote:I wonder how many of you would cope with a school trip to The Somme, not once but every year, time after time. The pupils learn the facts at school but try coping with dozens of pupils weeping at the reality of it all. Probably the first time in their lives they realise how others suffered to keep this country free. Row upon row of graves, the quietness and sense of calm. No parents there to console them, just their friends and teachers. Try keeping a watchful eye on them all, ensuring they are safe and supported in their visit. Maybe some of you should pay a visit to The Somme, it may just remove some of the bitterness and jealousy you have. You really haven't a clue.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
I think you are living in some surreal world
simong
says...
3:12pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason wrote:Priceless ! - Maybe during this annual trip to the Somme they can spend some time on reflecting how lucky they are to have a well paid job, with such excellent conditions and benefits rather than moaning about having to look after these kids (their job !).
goatty wrote:I wonder how many of you would cope with a school trip to The Somme, not once but every year, time after time. The pupils learn the facts at school but try coping with dozens of pupils weeping at the reality of it all. Probably the first time in their lives they realise how others suffered to keep this country free. Row upon row of graves, the quietness and sense of calm. No parents there to console them, just their friends and teachers. Try keeping a watchful eye on them all, ensuring they are safe and supported in their visit. Maybe some of you should pay a visit to The Somme, it may just remove some of the bitterness and jealousy you have. You really haven't a clue.High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul! Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much! 50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home! Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.Pablo23 wrote: I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.You talk some utter rubbish. The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
johngoodger
says...
3:18pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Well said by this MP!
I wonder what that dear Mr Milliband would comment?
MikeGB
says...
3:26pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Hessenford
says...
3:40pm Thu 21 Mar 13
goatty wrote:Don't forget the extra holidays when it snows.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Rustyfootballer
says...
3:54pm Thu 21 Mar 13
coypondboy
says...
4:58pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Teddy 1
says...
5:00pm Thu 21 Mar 13
ctrewyou
says...
5:09pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason wrote:A bit of a weird comment. Are you all right?
goatty wrote:I wonder how many of you would cope with a school trip to The Somme, not once but every year, time after time. The pupils learn the facts at school but try coping with dozens of pupils weeping at the reality of it all. Probably the first time in their lives they realise how others suffered to keep this country free. Row upon row of graves, the quietness and sense of calm. No parents there to console them, just their friends and teachers. Try keeping a watchful eye on them all, ensuring they are safe and supported in their visit. Maybe some of you should pay a visit to The Somme, it may just remove some of the bitterness and jealousy you have. You really haven't a clue.High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul! Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much! 50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home! Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.Pablo23 wrote: I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.You talk some utter rubbish. The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
ctrewyou
says...
5:12pm Thu 21 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:I thought teachers actually worked in schools. Where does the travel, accommodation, and meal allowance come from?
I am related to 2 teachers, one a teacher and 1 a headmaster. They do work hard yes, but the MP I am afraid is right. I get paid to work 40 hours a week. I am in sales so sometimes I have to stay away, which I am not paid for...but guess what, the company pays for my transport (same as teachers) pay for my accomodation (same as the teacher) and pay for my meals (oh same as teachers). Some weeks I must work 60 hours to get deals over the line and if we lose it, I do not get anything....it is called life...it is called work. If you do not like your job get another one / talk to your boss like we ALL have to do. Why is public sector so shielded from the reality of it? They would not last 5 minutes as an IT Trainer or a travelling coporate teacher teaching people software etc....I do not understand it. Come on teachers do us all a favour and wake up and smell the coffee, we are work really hard - deal with it!
blahblahbleurgh
says...
5:20pm Thu 21 Mar 13
radical
says...
5:39pm Thu 21 Mar 13
coypondboy wrote:Don't know where you get your info from but its total rubbish, a rise every year on top of their annual pay rise, are you on drugs or do you actually live in coypond
I work in the pensions industry and have calculated that most public sector workers receive between 25 and 30% on top of their bloated salaries as contributions from the tax payer to help fund their gold plated pension schemes and as for those who retire early due to stress this figure is even higher. They also get automatic pay rises every year for 7-8 yrs on top of their annual pay rise. Imagine getting that in the private sector.
ctrewyou
says...
6:09pm Thu 21 Mar 13
coypondboy wrote:Based on your calculations, you should not be working in the pensions industry, or any industry involving basic maths. Or reading. I dont understand why you think public sector workers have automatic pay rises when they have had a pay freeze for the last 3 years, and yesterdays budget extended that until 2016. And the last pension deal increased the contributions workers paytowards their 'bloated' pensions.
I work in the pensions industry and have calculated that most public sector workers receive between 25 and 30% on top of their bloated salaries as contributions from the tax payer to help fund their gold plated pension schemes and as for those who retire early due to stress this figure is even higher. They also get automatic pay rises every year for 7-8 yrs on top of their annual pay rise. Imagine getting that in the private sector.
As you will be aware, working in the industry, that the average publc pension is less than £3,000 a year. I would not agree that is a 'gold plated' pension.
You say you work in the pensions industry, do they let you near any numbers?
BackOfTheNet
says...
6:21pm Thu 21 Mar 13
I wonder why you don't if it's so simple?
Dibbles2
says...
6:31pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason wrote:Our kids are lucky if they get a trip to Hengistbury head!
goatty wrote:I wonder how many of you would cope with a school trip to The Somme, not once but every year, time after time. The pupils learn the facts at school but try coping with dozens of pupils weeping at the reality of it all. Probably the first time in their lives they realise how others suffered to keep this country free. Row upon row of graves, the quietness and sense of calm. No parents there to console them, just their friends and teachers. Try keeping a watchful eye on them all, ensuring they are safe and supported in their visit. Maybe some of you should pay a visit to The Somme, it may just remove some of the bitterness and jealousy you have. You really haven't a clue.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
High Treason
says...
6:31pm Thu 21 Mar 13
afcb-loyal wrote:Such a reply is expected from a loyal supporter of EM's money machine. If you had read my posts you would have discovered I am not a teacher.
high Treason if thats the best excuse you can come up with why your job is so hard i rest my case.
Knowing some of the brainless, foul mouthed, unkempt children parents send to school never would I wish to teach.
Dibbles2
says...
6:43pm Thu 21 Mar 13
ctrewyou
says...
7:49pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Dibbles2 wrote:But it's not the teachers fault you are experiencing the difficulties you describe. But it does suit the government for us to be blaming everyone except the people holding the purse strings. The government, actually does have enough money to pay everyone a decent wage and a pension, but choose instead to reward their banker friends with multi-million pound deals and pensions. But it's easier to have a go at a teacher bankers, who actually have caused the mess we are in, not teachers, or any public sector workers. Yesterday, Barclays reported they paid one of their managers over £17 MILLION as a bonus. How mant teachers salaries would that pay for?
I am utterly astounded by comments of jealousy? Where does that come from. British people are fed up of people who get a far better deal than non public sector workers heaping more misery on those that have no option but to work long hours with 4 weeks holiday. People and families who suffer during the holidays due to childcare costs who dont get paid if the schools shut for a day who are scraping together enough money to put food on the dinner table. Those same people who state we chose our lifestyle! Well perhaps some of us are professionals who have hit on hard times and are not jealous or thick but downright fed up! Who dread the next school trip letter that the kids give us, who dont get free school meals, subsidised school trips and all the other benefits that the benefit culture allows. I am constantly hassled by my sons school because he doesnt hand his homework in. Because at his age I dont have the time to sit down with him and help him because I work so bloody hard and yet my son gets punished for this. Now let think why non teaching but working parents are so fed up!
blahblahbleurgh
says...
7:50pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Dibbles2 wrote:Totally agree i work loads of hours pay for childcare so i can go to work in the hols not entitled to any help havent had a pay rise in 4yr and i dont have a pension.Yet im not striking i look after elderly with dementia if we striked who would look after these people. Teachers should be thinking the same about the kids in their care
I am utterly astounded by comments of jealousy? Where does that come from. British people are fed up of people who get a far better deal than non public sector workers heaping more misery on those that have no option but to work long hours with 4 weeks holiday. People and families who suffer during the holidays due to childcare costs who dont get paid if the schools shut for a day who are scraping together enough money to put food on the dinner table. Those same people who state we chose our lifestyle! Well perhaps some of us are professionals who have hit on hard times and are not jealous or thick but downright fed up! Who dread the next school trip letter that the kids give us, who dont get free school meals, subsidised school trips and all the other benefits that the benefit culture allows. I am constantly hassled by my sons school because he doesnt hand his homework in. Because at his age I dont have the time to sit down with him and help him because I work so bloody hard and yet my son gets punished for this. Now let think why non teaching but working parents are so fed up!
blahblahbleurgh
says...
7:54pm Thu 21 Mar 13
ctrewyou wrote:The government doesnt pay bankers salaries though the banks do. Barclays is independant so they can pay their staff whatever they want however obscene it is
Dibbles2 wrote:But it's not the teachers fault you are experiencing the difficulties you describe. But it does suit the government for us to be blaming everyone except the people holding the purse strings. The government, actually does have enough money to pay everyone a decent wage and a pension, but choose instead to reward their banker friends with multi-million pound deals and pensions. But it's easier to have a go at a teacher bankers, who actually have caused the mess we are in, not teachers, or any public sector workers. Yesterday, Barclays reported they paid one of their managers over £17 MILLION as a bonus. How mant teachers salaries would that pay for?
I am utterly astounded by comments of jealousy? Where does that come from. British people are fed up of people who get a far better deal than non public sector workers heaping more misery on those that have no option but to work long hours with 4 weeks holiday. People and families who suffer during the holidays due to childcare costs who dont get paid if the schools shut for a day who are scraping together enough money to put food on the dinner table. Those same people who state we chose our lifestyle! Well perhaps some of us are professionals who have hit on hard times and are not jealous or thick but downright fed up! Who dread the next school trip letter that the kids give us, who dont get free school meals, subsidised school trips and all the other benefits that the benefit culture allows. I am constantly hassled by my sons school because he doesnt hand his homework in. Because at his age I dont have the time to sit down with him and help him because I work so bloody hard and yet my son gets punished for this. Now let think why non teaching but working parents are so fed up!
fossilmole
says...
8:15pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Pablo23 wrote:Before making silly comments like this ...YOU TRY TEACHING...see how long you could keep it going..
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
Bigman101
says...
8:29pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Gove tells you educational standards are dropping. International research says we are the 6th best in the world: http://www.bbc.co.uk
/news/education-2049
8356
Teachers have a gold plated pension scheme, the average is less than £10,000 per year if you do 30 years.
"I have not had a pay rise for years", neither have teachers who are now paying in more than £100 per month ( yes -£100 cash in your pocket) whilst having a pay freeze.
By the way you might want to look at what independent academics are saying before you criticise teachers for endangering your children's education
The Leveson scared press are being well manipulated by an ex journo, and by the way he wants to change every single syllabus in the country. You can now choose whether you want to pay for teachers to be able to teach this or schools that have additional funding streams to get ahead.
Bigman101
says...
8:36pm Thu 21 Mar 13
usiness-21879797
apm1954
says...
8:58pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Bigman101
says...
9:01pm Thu 21 Mar 13
sezzler
says...
9:02pm Thu 21 Mar 13
1 Most teachers work 50-60 hours plus per week.
2 They plan their own lessons- lesson plans can not be bought off the shelf - even purchased schemes (which few teachers use) need to be adapted for each lesson.
3 Teachers do need to produce good lessons or they CAN lose their jobs (rightly so).
4 It is not a guaranteed job for life- look at what is happening in the Purbecks.
5 Training days were taken off teachers' holiday entitlement not added to existing holidays.
6 Snow days happen because for many schools it is not always possible for teachers living miles away to get to school (or the buses don't run to transport the pupils). It used to be that teachers would go to the nearest school to their house to teach. This is no longer permitted due to the necessity of CRB checks.
7 Teaching is a great job because you get to work with great children and make a difference.
I HAVE worked in industry AND education.
In industry you leave your job at the door. In teaching you take the work home with you, both literally and metaphorically.
Stop bashing teachers, you are playing into the government's hands!
apm1954
says...
9:10pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Bigman101 wrote:sooner the better cant wait
an original and well thought out answer apm1954, if that is your year of birth are you about to take a nice long holiday?
Roband65
says...
9:14pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Bigman101
says...
9:15pm Thu 21 Mar 13
en for 8 more years than you will work for with the exact same thought in their minds, looking after 30 13 year olds and providing a good education at 67 will be positive for the economy
Bigman101
says...
9:18pm Thu 21 Mar 13
sezzler
says...
9:30pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Bigman101 wrote:Absolutely. I shudder to think how it will be teaching 30 13 year olds when I am 68. How will I possibly relate to them? How will I have the energy to give them good lessons? It is not just about the impact working longer will have on teachers, it is also about the impact on the children.
Glad you want people teaching your children/grandchildr
en for 8 more years than you will work for with the exact same thought in their minds, looking after 30 13 year olds and providing a good education at 67 will be positive for the economy
ctrewyou
says...
9:30pm Thu 21 Mar 13
blahblahbleurgh wrote:But the government sets the tax rates, and tells people, via their friends at the Daily Mail etc, that it's the public sector workers on £3000 / year pensions who are being greedy and to blame for the economic crisis, not the bankers on multi-million pound salaries, who dont pay proper taxes.
ctrewyou wrote:The government doesnt pay bankers salaries though the banks do. Barclays is independant so they can pay their staff whatever they want however obscene it is
Dibbles2 wrote:But it's not the teachers fault you are experiencing the difficulties you describe. But it does suit the government for us to be blaming everyone except the people holding the purse strings. The government, actually does have enough money to pay everyone a decent wage and a pension, but choose instead to reward their banker friends with multi-million pound deals and pensions. But it's easier to have a go at a teacher bankers, who actually have caused the mess we are in, not teachers, or any public sector workers. Yesterday, Barclays reported they paid one of their managers over £17 MILLION as a bonus. How mant teachers salaries would that pay for?
I am utterly astounded by comments of jealousy? Where does that come from. British people are fed up of people who get a far better deal than non public sector workers heaping more misery on those that have no option but to work long hours with 4 weeks holiday. People and families who suffer during the holidays due to childcare costs who dont get paid if the schools shut for a day who are scraping together enough money to put food on the dinner table. Those same people who state we chose our lifestyle! Well perhaps some of us are professionals who have hit on hard times and are not jealous or thick but downright fed up! Who dread the next school trip letter that the kids give us, who dont get free school meals, subsidised school trips and all the other benefits that the benefit culture allows. I am constantly hassled by my sons school because he doesnt hand his homework in. Because at his age I dont have the time to sit down with him and help him because I work so bloody hard and yet my son gets punished for this. Now let think why non teaching but working parents are so fed up!
sezzler
says...
9:35pm Thu 21 Mar 13
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Bigman101
says...
9:43pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Dazed88
says...
9:48pm Thu 21 Mar 13
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
Pablo23
says...
9:57pm Thu 21 Mar 13
High Treason wrote:I wish I got paid as much as Ricky Gervais for my slightly provocative, satirical comments.
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
muscliffman
says...
11:09pm Thu 21 Mar 13
(No, I don't read the Daily Mail thank you but nor do I or most Echo readers I suspect enjoy the very agreeable employment terms, pensions and job security teachers currently have)
s-pb2
says...
11:20pm Thu 21 Mar 13
afcb-loyal wrote:Cliche alert!!!!
Half the teachers at my son and daughters schools are pathetic..
Winton and Glenmoor have slowly gone downhill over the last 10 years promising this and that every time there is a parent evening and in reality it just gets worse.
The kids are in charge not the teachers.
Half are too young for the job and lack experience and are frightened of the kids.
Before all you teacher defenders come on here moaning about my post its true i have had to put up with sh1te teaching for the five years they been there with no change.
Training days, holidays, snow, live in the real world for gods sake.
There are a couple of "old school" teachers there that do not fall in the above category.
Dibbles2
says...
11:26pm Thu 21 Mar 13
Dazed88 wrote:No but take into account we get 20 working days holiday, 3 of those days are teacher training days(sometimes more) 1 inset day, 3 half days, school closure and now strike action. WE ALL WORK HARD you have to see the general publics point of view. The comments of jealousy are ridiculous of the teachers commenting on here are correct what is there to be jealous of? My uncle is head of year and he doesnt work 64 hours a week and he goes abroad for 10 weeks a year. Nice if you can afford it but most of us cant. Cue the despicabe comments about other people choosing their path in life!!!!!!!!!!!!
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
Dibbles2
says...
11:29pm Thu 21 Mar 13
ctrewyou wrote:Did I say it was teachers fault? I am pointing out many people work just as hard and yet they suffer when schools close.
Dibbles2 wrote:But it's not the teachers fault you are experiencing the difficulties you describe. But it does suit the government for us to be blaming everyone except the people holding the purse strings. The government, actually does have enough money to pay everyone a decent wage and a pension, but choose instead to reward their banker friends with multi-million pound deals and pensions. But it's easier to have a go at a teacher bankers, who actually have caused the mess we are in, not teachers, or any public sector workers. Yesterday, Barclays reported they paid one of their managers over £17 MILLION as a bonus. How mant teachers salaries would that pay for?
I am utterly astounded by comments of jealousy? Where does that come from. British people are fed up of people who get a far better deal than non public sector workers heaping more misery on those that have no option but to work long hours with 4 weeks holiday. People and families who suffer during the holidays due to childcare costs who dont get paid if the schools shut for a day who are scraping together enough money to put food on the dinner table. Those same people who state we chose our lifestyle! Well perhaps some of us are professionals who have hit on hard times and are not jealous or thick but downright fed up! Who dread the next school trip letter that the kids give us, who dont get free school meals, subsidised school trips and all the other benefits that the benefit culture allows. I am constantly hassled by my sons school because he doesnt hand his homework in. Because at his age I dont have the time to sit down with him and help him because I work so bloody hard and yet my son gets punished for this. Now let think why non teaching but working parents are so fed up!
Phixer
says...
5:50am Fri 22 Mar 13
pauls55 wrote:We could say that about many jobs in the private sector for one reason or another.
I'd like to see how the usual moaners here who really believe all the stereotypes fed to them by right wing rags like the Daily Mail on Teachers and their so called life of luxury would manage facing a class room of children every morning, bet you lot wouldn't last five minutes. Teachers do one of the most valuable jobs possible and deserve respect not the usual trite comments seen here.
The issue is that people in these taxpayer funded jobs have chosen the wrong time to demand more money when those of us who pay their wages have had our own incomes reduced.
I don't remember teachers supporting the private sector when private pension funds were robbed by McBroon.
I don't remember teachers complaining when the family gold was sold off by McBroon at a low price thanks to his telling the world in advance.
Where do teachers think all this extra money is going to come from? Higher taxation? And, no, public servants do not pay tax; what they return to the government as PAYE/NIC/VAT has been given to them in the first place from private sector taxpayers. The private sector pays for their holidays, fish suppers, xmas presents, etc.
This is not to complain that teachers or others are not necessary, nor that they don't do a good job, but, if they are going to keep quiet about the vast increase in public non-jobs then they are going to feel the backlash when the money runs out.
Phixer
says...
6:01am Fri 22 Mar 13
sea poole wrote:Blame Bliar & McBroon for borrowing money to create too many non-jobs in the public sector. Now the chickens are coming home to roost.
Interesting that most comments talk about security of the teaching profession- there's a considerable number of redundancies being made within the profession, based on shrinking school budgets...and for those of you who are envious of the 'long holidays' and relatively short 'working week' why not swallow your envy and join the ranks of the profession- it's obviously causing you so much jealousy...
If you haven't been out for a while, you won't have noticed that this country cannot keep spending money that we don't have.
I would have thought that teachers would be able to work out that increasing the number of non-jobs has to be financed by a reducing number of real taxpayers, who themselves have come under pressure to retain jobs.
Teachers are going to have difficulty gaining public support when the schools are closed for 13 weeks and then, just when they re-open, they close again for 'training days' causing disruption in many family homes.
And then I don't have to be a cynic to realise that you want to strike when students are doing exams.
Students only have one chance; teachers have had theirs and secured a good job.
justsayithowitis
says...
6:44am Fri 22 Mar 13
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
l'anglais
says...
8:21am Fri 22 Mar 13
A century ago the Labour party was the political wing formed to protected its trade union members interests.
During the following 50 years it created the NHS and improved conditions for the nations poor as a whole.
Unfortunately it lost it's socialist remit 30 years ago and does little for the workers and poor today, now becoming a populist centre ground party.
100 years ago the world needed to be rid itself of it's imperialist shackles, that came to a climax in the first and second world wars.
The brave new world was either communism or fascism, both were wrongly implemented by the barbaric thugs Stalin and Hitler.
Today's imperialists are Capitalists and need to realise that Society (through Nurses, Teachers and Police) needs to be backed and not considered hangers on, as half the fools on here will have you believe.
The Liberal
says...
8:41am Fri 22 Mar 13
DrBos1000
says...
9:34am Fri 22 Mar 13
Say-it-how-it-is
says...
10:36am Fri 22 Mar 13
DrBos1000 wrote:I think they should be all self employed then they will know what hard work is all about. You don't get paid holidays or sick pay. That will upset them with their 13 weeks of a year. I'm self employed and you work hard for what you do. I even work when I'm ill witch I never use to do when being employed. So make them self employed. They will soon stop moaning then.
I agree with him, i have been self employed for 20 years they are lucky to have a job and monthly salary - get on with what you are paid to do
The Liberal
says...
11:11am Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal
says...
11:15am Fri 22 Mar 13
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
justsayithowitis
says...
11:43am Fri 22 Mar 13
cherrydragon
says...
12:34pm Fri 22 Mar 13
Trade unions were great for brining much needed equality and equal opportunities to all, for that, we must all be grateful.
But calling a strike in a recession when everyone else is suffering too - I mean it does not take a genius with any qualifications to work out that this is such a poor piece of PR.
Rather than saying that everyone is jealous and know nothing, why not think why people are saying negative things in the first place and perhaps find another way to sort out your issues in your employment.
I do not believe any Teacher or Pro-Strike or Pro-Union person on this board can provide a counter argument to the fact that if any private sector worker goes on strike, we do NOT, I repeat DO NOT get a better deal whilst teachers going on strike have a job to walk back into and usually get a deal. Holding the country's children to ransom over your own pockets / work conditions makes you just as bad as those you are criticising.
At the end of the day, union leaders will still get paid, they are jusifying their jobs by making a strike. The only people that win are the union CEO's - everyone else loses.
enjoy!
The Liberal
says...
12:36pm Fri 22 Mar 13
justsayithowitis wrote:Pardon? What's it got to do with averages? It seems to me that you set up a straw-man argument of teachers working 365 a year (no one else claimed that) just so you could rubbish it.
Dazed88 said average. That is average. It is also a load of rubbish
If that's your idea of 'just saying it how it is', good luck to you.
The Liberal
says...
12:42pm Fri 22 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:You do realise that all employees – not just public sector ones – have a right to take industrial action without fear of being fired? From www.gov.uk:
I think the point that is missed here is that for most private sector workers, a strike / refusal to come into work = no job whereas those in the Teaching Profession strike / refusal to come into work = more pay (hopefully) or better conditions.
Trade unions were great for brining much needed equality and equal opportunities to all, for that, we must all be grateful.
But calling a strike in a recession when everyone else is suffering too - I mean it does not take a genius with any qualifications to work out that this is such a poor piece of PR.
Rather than saying that everyone is jealous and know nothing, why not think why people are saying negative things in the first place and perhaps find another way to sort out your issues in your employment.
I do not believe any Teacher or Pro-Strike or Pro-Union person on this board can provide a counter argument to the fact that if any private sector worker goes on strike, we do NOT, I repeat DO NOT get a better deal whilst teachers going on strike have a job to walk back into and usually get a deal. Holding the country's children to ransom over your own pockets / work conditions makes you just as bad as those you are criticising.
At the end of the day, union leaders will still get paid, they are jusifying their jobs by making a strike. The only people that win are the union CEO's - everyone else loses.
enjoy!
You can’t be dismissed for industrial action if:
- it’s called as a result of a properly organised ballot
- it’s about a trade dispute between workers and their employer (eg about your terms and conditions)
- a detailed notice about the industrial action (which is legally required) has been given to the employer at least 7 days before it begins
cherrydragon
says...
12:46pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:I agree with you and agree that it is easy to look at jobs from the outside and pick holes at it.
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
But surely can you not understand that going on strike from a paid job looking after the nation's future minds and walking back in to the job whilst the nation reels in pain from a recession - surely you are not blind and can see why there is so much upset? This is not a question of standards at all.
It beggars belief how teachers can even consider this. Sure, anyone would sympathise if they were grossly underpaid or having all their jobs cut radically....but this is not the case??
The Liberal
says...
12:48pm Fri 22 Mar 13
Bigman101 wrote:How do you know everyone supporting the teachers is a teacher? I'm certainly not. In fact, I'm self-employed myself, so I know what it's like to work hard for every penny. Yet I want my child to get the best education possible, which requires the best teachers. And you won't get that by paying them peanuts.
Interesting that there have only been 2 "anti-teacher" comments since 5pm, and lots of pro teacher ones since, maybe those hard working types have more time on their hands than teachers who actually start to comment when they actually finish their work.
cherrydragon
says...
12:50pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:Sorry Liberal, but the reality is, that although this maybe the case officially, it does not work like that in reality. It just doesn't as not many private sector jobs have a monopoly on talent nor do most private sector jobs conduct a service that if I went on strike, would cripple the nation.
cherrydragon wrote:You do realise that all employees – not just public sector ones – have a right to take industrial action without fear of being fired? From www.gov.uk:
I think the point that is missed here is that for most private sector workers, a strike / refusal to come into work = no job whereas those in the Teaching Profession strike / refusal to come into work = more pay (hopefully) or better conditions.
Trade unions were great for brining much needed equality and equal opportunities to all, for that, we must all be grateful.
But calling a strike in a recession when everyone else is suffering too - I mean it does not take a genius with any qualifications to work out that this is such a poor piece of PR.
Rather than saying that everyone is jealous and know nothing, why not think why people are saying negative things in the first place and perhaps find another way to sort out your issues in your employment.
I do not believe any Teacher or Pro-Strike or Pro-Union person on this board can provide a counter argument to the fact that if any private sector worker goes on strike, we do NOT, I repeat DO NOT get a better deal whilst teachers going on strike have a job to walk back into and usually get a deal. Holding the country's children to ransom over your own pockets / work conditions makes you just as bad as those you are criticising.
At the end of the day, union leaders will still get paid, they are jusifying their jobs by making a strike. The only people that win are the union CEO's - everyone else loses.
enjoy!
You can’t be dismissed for industrial action if:
- it’s called as a result of a properly organised ballot
- it’s about a trade dispute between workers and their employer (eg about your terms and conditions)
- a detailed notice about the industrial action (which is legally required) has been given to the employer at least 7 days before it begins
The teaching profession does however have far more ramifications when on strike then the vast majority of private sector roles.
The Liberal
says...
12:53pm Fri 22 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:It may be bad PR, but teachers' pension funds have already effectively been raided – not once, but twice. What do you propose they do about the gradual erosion of their pay and conditions? Roll over and have their tummies tickled?
The Liberal wrote:I agree with you and agree that it is easy to look at jobs from the outside and pick holes at it.
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
But surely can you not understand that going on strike from a paid job looking after the nation's future minds and walking back in to the job whilst the nation reels in pain from a recession - surely you are not blind and can see why there is so much upset? This is not a question of standards at all.
It beggars belief how teachers can even consider this. Sure, anyone would sympathise if they were grossly underpaid or having all their jobs cut radically....but this is not the case??
cherrydragon
says...
12:53pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal
says...
12:55pm Fri 22 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:Private sector employees' leverage in this respect may indeed be weaker. I was merely pointing out that it is illegal to dismiss someone for taking industrial action, so your original claim that someone in the private sector would be fired was false.
The Liberal wrote:Sorry Liberal, but the reality is, that although this maybe the case officially, it does not work like that in reality. It just doesn't as not many private sector jobs have a monopoly on talent nor do most private sector jobs conduct a service that if I went on strike, would cripple the nation.
cherrydragon wrote:You do realise that all employees – not just public sector ones – have a right to take industrial action without fear of being fired? From www.gov.uk:
I think the point that is missed here is that for most private sector workers, a strike / refusal to come into work = no job whereas those in the Teaching Profession strike / refusal to come into work = more pay (hopefully) or better conditions.
Trade unions were great for brining much needed equality and equal opportunities to all, for that, we must all be grateful.
But calling a strike in a recession when everyone else is suffering too - I mean it does not take a genius with any qualifications to work out that this is such a poor piece of PR.
Rather than saying that everyone is jealous and know nothing, why not think why people are saying negative things in the first place and perhaps find another way to sort out your issues in your employment.
I do not believe any Teacher or Pro-Strike or Pro-Union person on this board can provide a counter argument to the fact that if any private sector worker goes on strike, we do NOT, I repeat DO NOT get a better deal whilst teachers going on strike have a job to walk back into and usually get a deal. Holding the country's children to ransom over your own pockets / work conditions makes you just as bad as those you are criticising.
At the end of the day, union leaders will still get paid, they are jusifying their jobs by making a strike. The only people that win are the union CEO's - everyone else loses.
enjoy!
You can’t be dismissed for industrial action if:
- it’s called as a result of a properly organised ballot
- it’s about a trade dispute between workers and their employer (eg about your terms and conditions)
- a detailed notice about the industrial action (which is legally required) has been given to the employer at least 7 days before it begins
The teaching profession does however have far more ramifications when on strike then the vast majority of private sector roles.
skydriver
says...
12:55pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The reason these teachers are up in arms is because of what this government has been doing to the working folk. There pension pots are very well secure, so much so they are having a pensions holiday, although that doesn't get mentioned very much.
Good on you teachers I support you 100%.
cherrydragon
says...
12:57pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:I expect to do what everyone else has been doing with job cuts, pay and condition cuts; 1: Take the hit or 2: open a dialogue but dont hold our country or children to ransom to line your own pockets - that is what I would expect a rational person to do.
cherrydragon wrote:It may be bad PR, but teachers' pension funds have already effectively been raided – not once, but twice. What do you propose they do about the gradual erosion of their pay and conditions? Roll over and have their tummies tickled?
The Liberal wrote:I agree with you and agree that it is easy to look at jobs from the outside and pick holes at it.
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
But surely can you not understand that going on strike from a paid job looking after the nation's future minds and walking back in to the job whilst the nation reels in pain from a recession - surely you are not blind and can see why there is so much upset? This is not a question of standards at all.
It beggars belief how teachers can even consider this. Sure, anyone would sympathise if they were grossly underpaid or having all their jobs cut radically....but this is not the case??
Also, Teachers are employed by society. They should get society on side before cheesing everyone off surely??
cherrydragon
says...
1:00pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:Ignorance is bliss
cherrydragon wrote:Private sector employees' leverage in this respect may indeed be weaker. I was merely pointing out that it is illegal to dismiss someone for taking industrial action, so your original claim that someone in the private sector would be fired was false.
The Liberal wrote:Sorry Liberal, but the reality is, that although this maybe the case officially, it does not work like that in reality. It just doesn't as not many private sector jobs have a monopoly on talent nor do most private sector jobs conduct a service that if I went on strike, would cripple the nation.
cherrydragon wrote:You do realise that all employees – not just public sector ones – have a right to take industrial action without fear of being fired? From www.gov.uk:
I think the point that is missed here is that for most private sector workers, a strike / refusal to come into work = no job whereas those in the Teaching Profession strike / refusal to come into work = more pay (hopefully) or better conditions.
Trade unions were great for brining much needed equality and equal opportunities to all, for that, we must all be grateful.
But calling a strike in a recession when everyone else is suffering too - I mean it does not take a genius with any qualifications to work out that this is such a poor piece of PR.
Rather than saying that everyone is jealous and know nothing, why not think why people are saying negative things in the first place and perhaps find another way to sort out your issues in your employment.
I do not believe any Teacher or Pro-Strike or Pro-Union person on this board can provide a counter argument to the fact that if any private sector worker goes on strike, we do NOT, I repeat DO NOT get a better deal whilst teachers going on strike have a job to walk back into and usually get a deal. Holding the country's children to ransom over your own pockets / work conditions makes you just as bad as those you are criticising.
At the end of the day, union leaders will still get paid, they are jusifying their jobs by making a strike. The only people that win are the union CEO's - everyone else loses.
enjoy!
You can’t be dismissed for industrial action if:
- it’s called as a result of a properly organised ballot
- it’s about a trade dispute between workers and their employer (eg about your terms and conditions)
- a detailed notice about the industrial action (which is legally required) has been given to the employer at least 7 days before it begins
The teaching profession does however have far more ramifications when on strike then the vast majority of private sector roles.
cherrydragon
says...
1:01pm Fri 22 Mar 13
skydriver wrote:The government always screws over people - but I will never be convinced striking is the option when dealing with such a valuable asset as educating our children.
Come the next election he may well not have a job, so I suggest he keep stumm.
The reason these teachers are up in arms is because of what this government has been doing to the working folk. There pension pots are very well secure, so much so they are having a pensions holiday, although that doesn't get mentioned very much.
Good on you teachers I support you 100%.
Sorry.
And you are right, I better stop commenting or I will lose my job today! :-O
cherrydragon
says...
1:07pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal
says...
1:08pm Fri 22 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:It's a last resort, because Mr Gove won't engage in genuine dialogue with the teachers.
skydriver wrote:The government always screws over people - but I will never be convinced striking is the option when dealing with such a valuable asset as educating our children.
Come the next election he may well not have a job, so I suggest he keep stumm.
The reason these teachers are up in arms is because of what this government has been doing to the working folk. There pension pots are very well secure, so much so they are having a pensions holiday, although that doesn't get mentioned very much.
Good on you teachers I support you 100%.
Sorry.
And you are right, I better stop commenting or I will lose my job today! :-O
cherrydragon
says...
1:12pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:Yes, I agree with you there. I do think Mr Grove should be receiving the heat because in affect, he is ultimately at the top of the pyramid - anger should really be directed at him....his staff effectively are revolting against him, what a shambles. Maybe the question that I should ask is WHY do teachers feel the need to strike?
cherrydragon wrote:It's a last resort, because Mr Gove won't engage in genuine dialogue with the teachers.
skydriver wrote:The government always screws over people - but I will never be convinced striking is the option when dealing with such a valuable asset as educating our children.
Come the next election he may well not have a job, so I suggest he keep stumm.
The reason these teachers are up in arms is because of what this government has been doing to the working folk. There pension pots are very well secure, so much so they are having a pensions holiday, although that doesn't get mentioned very much.
Good on you teachers I support you 100%.
Sorry.
And you are right, I better stop commenting or I will lose my job today! :-O
justsayithowitis
says...
1:12pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:Dazed88 said that on average a teacher worked 2560 hours a year. So on average that works out at over 7 hours each and every day of the year. If you cannot understand averages stop making stupid comments
justsayithowitis wrote:Pardon? What's it got to do with averages? It seems to me that you set up a straw-man argument of teachers working 365 a year (no one else claimed that) just so you could rubbish it.
Dazed88 said average. That is average. It is also a load of rubbish
If that's your idea of 'just saying it how it is', good luck to you.
kingstonpaul
says...
1:24pm Fri 22 Mar 13
The Echo is again guilty of taking a perfectly reasonable statement of fact and grotesquely twisting it into something more incendiary.
How anyone could take offence at such take offence at such a bland utterance from the MP is totally beyond me.
l'anglais
says...
2:12pm Fri 22 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:Strike action is not taken lightly.
The Liberal wrote:Yes, I agree with you there. I do think Mr Grove should be receiving the heat because in affect, he is ultimately at the top of the pyramid - anger should really be directed at him....his staff effectively are revolting against him, what a shambles. Maybe the question that I should ask is WHY do teachers feel the need to strike?
cherrydragon wrote:It's a last resort, because Mr Gove won't engage in genuine dialogue with the teachers.
skydriver wrote:The government always screws over people - but I will never be convinced striking is the option when dealing with such a valuable asset as educating our children.
Come the next election he may well not have a job, so I suggest he keep stumm.
The reason these teachers are up in arms is because of what this government has been doing to the working folk. There pension pots are very well secure, so much so they are having a pensions holiday, although that doesn't get mentioned very much.
Good on you teachers I support you 100%.
Sorry.
And you are right, I better stop commenting or I will lose my job today! :-O
However, everyone has the right to withdraw their work (non-remunerated of course) if they do not agree with the conditions laid down by their employer.
Unfortunately if an individual engaged in such a unilateral dispute withe their employer, then little headway would be made.
However joining a Trade Union increase's one's power of dialogue.
Workers in the public sector have retained some pride, something that the tories destroyed in the 1980's for those of us in the private sector.
sezzler
says...
5:02pm Fri 22 Mar 13
justsayithowitis wrote:7 hours a day? I wish- more like 11! Perhaps only 3-5 hours per day at the weekend- unless reports time or end of unit marking.
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
watson443
says...
6:23pm Fri 22 Mar 13
Herbert Austin wrote:haha well said
logic subroutine wrote:Those who do not move do not notice their chains. Luxemberg.
Could not agree more. I've not had a pay rise for 6 years now, times have been tough where I work, but I am grateful that my MD has kept things going and we all still have a job!
Teachers are not special. We all contribute to the sum total of the countries future. Do your job like the rest of us.
I worry about the children being taught by people with such a skewed view of reality...
EGHH
says...
9:01am Sat 23 Mar 13
jsdorset
says...
10:22am Sat 23 Mar 13
Lets be honest, as the saying goes..... "Those that can, do, and those that can't teach" Be thankful you have a job as there are a lot worse off people than you.
Cherry19
says...
11:25am Sat 23 Mar 13
Phixer
says...
11:53am Sat 23 Mar 13
EGHH wrote:How convenient to forget that it was your friend McBroon that robbed private pension funds, not forgetting that he sold off the family gold at a loss - having told the world in advance that he was going to do it.
Typical Tory MP attitude to the workers of Britain. Cameron has taken Britain back to the age of Dickens. What next? Workhouses?
Not forgetting 11 years of your friends creating too many non-jobs financed by loans we cannot afford.
Ah, such short memories!
Bluewit
says...
1:44pm Sat 23 Mar 13
chrisii1991 wrote:think Mr Roberts needs to wake up..what has Swayne said that is not true...!!..think PAYE and public service especially read about the current events through a long distance buffer. Its tragic chaos out here in the sharp end of business and self employed and there is no help from the the authorities regardless of the rhetoric. Swayne has it spot on, hold on to those jobs and stop moaning about what you havn't got and what you can offer, i.e. some kids who can actually leave school equipped to compete in the world and not half equipped and molly collied to the point of being in shock, what can they offer, not what can they take. So completely out of touch to what is going on out here.
He is right though
nottingham
says...
3:45pm Sat 23 Mar 13
Mind you its a bit rich coming from MP's who are also feather bedded.
Both MP's and teachers are out of touch with reality
justsayithowitis
says...
4:18pm Sat 23 Mar 13
sezzler wrote:You don't get any holidays either I suppose. Do you only work 3-5 hours on Christmas Day or do the full 11. Does it depend what day of the week it falls on. I don't know why teachers can't be honest about how many hours they work
justsayithowitis wrote:7 hours a day? I wish- more like 11! Perhaps only 3-5 hours per day at the weekend- unless reports time or end of unit marking.
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
bobsworthforever
says...
10:08am Sun 24 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:Absolutely I had some of this " lucky to be in a job mentality " when I was working. Hope he might be out of a job one day could even be sooner than he thinks
Is Swayne implying that if he had his way, he'd do away with state education and they'd all be out of a job? Sounds like it.
justsayithowitis
says...
10:28am Sun 24 Mar 13
The Liberal wrote:This is the same for everyone. Times are hard. Why shouldn't you be treated the same as everyone else
cherrydragon wrote:It may be bad PR, but teachers' pension funds have already effectively been raided – not once, but twice. What do you propose they do about the gradual erosion of their pay and conditions? Roll over and have their tummies tickled?
The Liberal wrote:I agree with you and agree that it is easy to look at jobs from the outside and pick holes at it.
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
But surely can you not understand that going on strike from a paid job looking after the nation's future minds and walking back in to the job whilst the nation reels in pain from a recession - surely you are not blind and can see why there is so much upset? This is not a question of standards at all.
It beggars belief how teachers can even consider this. Sure, anyone would sympathise if they were grossly underpaid or having all their jobs cut radically....but this is not the case??
fossilmole
says...
12:58pm Sun 24 Mar 13
All the time we are putting effort into this the bankers. football 'nancies,' TV so-called celebs and City slickers are pulling millions out of the system ...quite often for doing very little of any importance.
'Workers of the World Unit' may be an old and worn out cry ...but it still holds true if you want a decent income in the face of the million£ grabbers
goatty
says...
2:30pm Sun 24 Mar 13
sezzler wrote:So you admit that the tax payer pays your pension fund. Very nice thank you!
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Also you fail to address the 13 weeks holiday, whereas most people enjoy only 4 weeks or 5 if they are lucky!
Also why after weeks and weeks off in the Summer do you need to take a Teachers Training day off the first day of term???
I cannot find any reports of teachers being made redundant or sack for incompetence. Wonder why that is??? Job for life maybe!
I wonder how long teachers would last in the real world...No pay rise, No Government paid pension, 4 weeks holiday, having to go to work when it snows and no chance of being made redundant?
fossilmole
says...
5:50pm Sun 24 Mar 13
goatty wrote:I repeat, MORE LOUDLY, what I said earler!!!!
sezzler wrote:So you admit that the tax payer pays your pension fund. Very nice thank you!
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Also you fail to address the 13 weeks holiday, whereas most people enjoy only 4 weeks or 5 if they are lucky!
Also why after weeks and weeks off in the Summer do you need to take a Teachers Training day off the first day of term???
I cannot find any reports of teachers being made redundant or sack for incompetence. Wonder why that is??? Job for life maybe!
I wonder how long teachers would last in the real world...No pay rise, No Government paid pension, 4 weeks holiday, having to go to work when it snows and no chance of being made redundant?
Why do we always seem to 'fall into the trap' where we end up arguing between ourselves about how and when we should stand up for our individual employment rights? I'm worse off than you...yah..boo!
All the time we are putting effort into this the bankers. football 'nancies,' TV so-called celebs and City slickers are pulling millions out of the system ...quite often for doing very little of any importance.
'Workers of the World Unit' may be an old and worn out cry ...but it still holds true if you want a decent income in the face of the million£ grabbers”
rozmister
says...
3:47pm Mon 25 Mar 13
Personally I work 52 hours on a really good week but normally closer to 57/58 and going up to as many as 67/68 on a really bad week. I have 2 jobs because I can't afford to live on my main wage (not after I've paid out tax, NI & student loan repayments). My boyfriend has one job but works the same amount of hours. We're both graduates trying to earn enough to live (and earning significantly less than a newly qualified teacher). Most of my class that I graduated with are in the same situation - sitting in the office until late or taking work home to try and make yourself shine so you can get ahead in a sea of fresh graduates.
Oh and I only get 4 weeks of holiday a year. So I do about 2736 hours per year and I can guarantee my take home is less than a teachers.
Life is hard, economic times are hard, it's struggle to live, save and pay into a pension. As much as it pains me to say it 'we're all in this together' (at least all us actual workers are) and striking because you want more when you're in a better position to most and your striking will affect other workers is never going to be popular.
There's such a them and us attitude towards teachers. Teachers often seem to believe they do the most worthwhile hardest job out of everyone and everyone else believes they do nothing. In reality I don't think it's that clear cut but while teachers insist they are the ones doing some kind of miracle work us mere mortals are incapable of they aren't going to win anyone over to their side.
madras
says...
6:04pm Mon 25 Mar 13
tinkerten
says...
8:30am Tue 26 Mar 13
sezzler
says...
8:39am Tue 26 Mar 13
rozmister wrote:I am not telling you about the long hours I work because I want people to feel sorry for teachers. (By the way, 50 hours a week is a good week!). It is because I am sick of people who think that teachers all finish at 3.15 and have an easy life. It is not miracle work, but most of the extra work we do is down to government 'initiatives', which actually take us away from the important things like teaching the children!!!
I can't believe the amount of people on here saying they work 50 - 60 hours a week like they deserve a medal. Wake up and realise that plenty of people work way over the 'average working week' of 40 hours these days. People may be contracted for Mon - Fri 9 - 5 but in reality it doesn't work out like that.
Personally I work 52 hours on a really good week but normally closer to 57/58 and going up to as many as 67/68 on a really bad week. I have 2 jobs because I can't afford to live on my main wage (not after I've paid out tax, NI & student loan repayments). My boyfriend has one job but works the same amount of hours. We're both graduates trying to earn enough to live (and earning significantly less than a newly qualified teacher). Most of my class that I graduated with are in the same situation - sitting in the office until late or taking work home to try and make yourself shine so you can get ahead in a sea of fresh graduates.
Oh and I only get 4 weeks of holiday a year. So I do about 2736 hours per year and I can guarantee my take home is less than a teachers.
Life is hard, economic times are hard, it's struggle to live, save and pay into a pension. As much as it pains me to say it 'we're all in this together' (at least all us actual workers are) and striking because you want more when you're in a better position to most and your striking will affect other workers is never going to be popular.
There's such a them and us attitude towards teachers. Teachers often seem to believe they do the most worthwhile hardest job out of everyone and everyone else believes they do nothing. In reality I don't think it's that clear cut but while teachers insist they are the ones doing some kind of miracle work us mere mortals are incapable of they aren't going to win anyone over to their side.
By the way, before the teacher bashers notice the time I am typing, the reason I am able to type this now is because after 3 70 hour weeks I have a chest infection and can not speak.
sezzler
says...
8:44am Tue 26 Mar 13
goatty wrote:We have not had a pay rise in years. I have worked in industry before teaching, the one thing I miss is leaving work at the office and not spending evenings worrying about children etc. I work from home on a snow day (by the way MANY parents love snow days too!).
sezzler wrote:So you admit that the tax payer pays your pension fund. Very nice thank you!
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Also you fail to address the 13 weeks holiday, whereas most people enjoy only 4 weeks or 5 if they are lucky!
Also why after weeks and weeks off in the Summer do you need to take a Teachers Training day off the first day of term???
I cannot find any reports of teachers being made redundant or sack for incompetence. Wonder why that is??? Job for life maybe!
I wonder how long teachers would last in the real world...No pay rise, No Government paid pension, 4 weeks holiday, having to go to work when it snows and no chance of being made redundant?
Finally, strange that teachers don't want to shout out that they are redundant or sacked due to incompetence. You would think they would want to announce it on the front page! Do a search for 'Purbeck teachers redundant'. Then please stop talking rubbish!
sezzler
says...
8:47am Tue 26 Mar 13
tinkerten wrote:Amazingly, parents often send their children to school without coats. Suppose that's teachers' faults too!
Someone commented that teachers are "Intelligent" and that others could not do their job. Are these the same intelligent people that let children play outside, without coats, in freezing conditions ? We see every day 90% of the children of Christchurch Jnr school, playing outside without coats. No wonder the become ill and ate then off school. Pokesdown jnr school even had lunch outside in the rain, during a school trip, that was not organized correctly, by these so called intelligent teachers.
sezzler
says...
8:52am Tue 26 Mar 13
justsayithowitis wrote:Top of the pay scale for a classroom teacher is about £32000. Clearly this is not a BAD salary but after 15 years in a professional job with a degree it compares less favourably than those in the private sector.
The Liberal wrote:This is the same for everyone. Times are hard. Why shouldn't you be treated the same as everyone else
cherrydragon wrote:It may be bad PR, but teachers' pension funds have already effectively been raided – not once, but twice. What do you propose they do about the gradual erosion of their pay and conditions? Roll over and have their tummies tickled?
The Liberal wrote:I agree with you and agree that it is easy to look at jobs from the outside and pick holes at it.
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
But surely can you not understand that going on strike from a paid job looking after the nation's future minds and walking back in to the job whilst the nation reels in pain from a recession - surely you are not blind and can see why there is so much upset? This is not a question of standards at all.
It beggars belief how teachers can even consider this. Sure, anyone would sympathise if they were grossly underpaid or having all their jobs cut radically....but this is not the case??
Dorset Logic
says...
11:01am Tue 26 Mar 13
cherrydragon
says...
12:17pm Wed 27 Mar 13
sezzler wrote:So? That is their choice of profession. It is like saying "After 10 years working on a checkout, I am still not earning 30k a year" .... well it is simple really,....get another job if you want more money? It is not about the money as far as I am concerned, it is about the audacity of striking when the rest of us do not have that luxury. Get a grip! At least they got a pension!
justsayithowitis wrote:Top of the pay scale for a classroom teacher is about £32000. Clearly this is not a BAD salary but after 15 years in a professional job with a degree it compares less favourably than those in the private sector.
The Liberal wrote:This is the same for everyone. Times are hard. Why shouldn't you be treated the same as everyone else
cherrydragon wrote:It may be bad PR, but teachers' pension funds have already effectively been raided – not once, but twice. What do you propose they do about the gradual erosion of their pay and conditions? Roll over and have their tummies tickled?
The Liberal wrote:I agree with you and agree that it is easy to look at jobs from the outside and pick holes at it.
justsayithowitis wrote:Who mentioned 365 days a year?
Dazed88 wrote:I think you are talking out of your backside. A teacher works over 7 hours a day 365 days a year do they. No weekends off, no holidays and not even Christmas Day off. Rubbish
Some of the comments on here are absolutely despicable.
My mother is a teacher, and has been for almost 30 years. The sheer amount of work she does is staggering. Coming home after a day of teaching children with autism & Asperger’s, she then spends, on average, four hours a night planning the next day’s lessons. To say that she is lazy & overpaid is absolutely disgusting. Including planning, she works for roughly 64 hours a week. I have had the pleasure of watching her work and she is inspiring, creative, engaging & kind.
None of you have the faintest idea of what teaching involves – all you see are the long holidays and the supposedly cushy hours. The average person will work 1920 hours a year – a teacher will work, on average, 2560.
Underworked? I don’t think so.
(Also, having a go for snow days? Do you think teachers are in control of the weather?)
64 hours per week x 40 = 2,560.
Maybe the other poster was exaggerating a bit, but teachers do a lot more work than most people give them credit for.
But surely can you not understand that going on strike from a paid job looking after the nation's future minds and walking back in to the job whilst the nation reels in pain from a recession - surely you are not blind and can see why there is so much upset? This is not a question of standards at all.
It beggars belief how teachers can even consider this. Sure, anyone would sympathise if they were grossly underpaid or having all their jobs cut radically....but this is not the case??
cherrydragon
says...
12:23pm Wed 27 Mar 13
sezzler wrote:Again another frustrating comment about money.
goatty wrote:We have not had a pay rise in years. I have worked in industry before teaching, the one thing I miss is leaving work at the office and not spending evenings worrying about children etc. I work from home on a snow day (by the way MANY parents love snow days too!).
sezzler wrote:So you admit that the tax payer pays your pension fund. Very nice thank you!
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Also you fail to address the 13 weeks holiday, whereas most people enjoy only 4 weeks or 5 if they are lucky!
Also why after weeks and weeks off in the Summer do you need to take a Teachers Training day off the first day of term???
I cannot find any reports of teachers being made redundant or sack for incompetence. Wonder why that is??? Job for life maybe!
I wonder how long teachers would last in the real world...No pay rise, No Government paid pension, 4 weeks holiday, having to go to work when it snows and no chance of being made redundant?
Finally, strange that teachers don't want to shout out that they are redundant or sacked due to incompetence. You would think they would want to announce it on the front page! Do a search for 'Purbeck teachers redundant'. Then please stop talking rubbish!
It amazes me people make career choices then moan about it later. In all jobs there are things we dont like. I hate it when a client calls me on the weekend (when I am not being paid) but I love my job overall and i have to take the rough with the smooth....
The funny thing is, if teachers want a rise, then you need less people going into the teaching profession. The government will then have to raise the salary bands to attract the staff. Simple rules of demand and supply. Sadly, the quality of teaching is slipping. IN MY OPINION I reckon this is more because class discipline is too restricitve, too much PC/non-PC laws and pointless paperwork.
I was taught by some great teachers WITHOUT an assistant and maintained total control over 30 kids of all backgrounds and behaviour-some of which was bad. Not sure why this has changed?
So I think the teaching profession has evolved and parents should realise that their little angels are not always co-operative.
That said, I could not and would not teach simply because i dont like the conditions, i dont have the patience and dont like the pay hence, I vote with my feet and I am in a profession I enjoy and do. But teachers cannot argue and say they are hard done by....no, we all are.
sezzler
says...
3:14pm Wed 27 Mar 13
cherrydragon wrote:It was a response to the previous points, not a moan about money. I made my choice and do a profession I love. I won't be striking, but am sick and tired of people attacking teachers citing outdated views of what they do.
sezzler wrote:Again another frustrating comment about money.
goatty wrote:We have not had a pay rise in years. I have worked in industry before teaching, the one thing I miss is leaving work at the office and not spending evenings worrying about children etc. I work from home on a snow day (by the way MANY parents love snow days too!).
sezzler wrote:So you admit that the tax payer pays your pension fund. Very nice thank you!
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Also you fail to address the 13 weeks holiday, whereas most people enjoy only 4 weeks or 5 if they are lucky!
Also why after weeks and weeks off in the Summer do you need to take a Teachers Training day off the first day of term???
I cannot find any reports of teachers being made redundant or sack for incompetence. Wonder why that is??? Job for life maybe!
I wonder how long teachers would last in the real world...No pay rise, No Government paid pension, 4 weeks holiday, having to go to work when it snows and no chance of being made redundant?
Finally, strange that teachers don't want to shout out that they are redundant or sacked due to incompetence. You would think they would want to announce it on the front page! Do a search for 'Purbeck teachers redundant'. Then please stop talking rubbish!
It amazes me people make career choices then moan about it later. In all jobs there are things we dont like. I hate it when a client calls me on the weekend (when I am not being paid) but I love my job overall and i have to take the rough with the smooth....
The funny thing is, if teachers want a rise, then you need less people going into the teaching profession. The government will then have to raise the salary bands to attract the staff. Simple rules of demand and supply. Sadly, the quality of teaching is slipping. IN MY OPINION I reckon this is more because class discipline is too restricitve, too much PC/non-PC laws and pointless paperwork.
I was taught by some great teachers WITHOUT an assistant and maintained total control over 30 kids of all backgrounds and behaviour-some of which was bad. Not sure why this has changed?
So I think the teaching profession has evolved and parents should realise that their little angels are not always co-operative.
That said, I could not and would not teach simply because i dont like the conditions, i dont have the patience and dont like the pay hence, I vote with my feet and I am in a profession I enjoy and do. But teachers cannot argue and say they are hard done by....no, we all are.
cherrydragon
says...
7:24pm Wed 27 Mar 13
sezzler wrote:I apologise for any offence. Some people do have an out dated view but on the other hand, the government has created a feeling of animosity which has been poorly managed in my opinion.
cherrydragon wrote:It was a response to the previous points, not a moan about money. I made my choice and do a profession I love. I won't be striking, but am sick and tired of people attacking teachers citing outdated views of what they do.
sezzler wrote:Again another frustrating comment about money.
goatty wrote:We have not had a pay rise in years. I have worked in industry before teaching, the one thing I miss is leaving work at the office and not spending evenings worrying about children etc. I work from home on a snow day (by the way MANY parents love snow days too!).
sezzler wrote:So you admit that the tax payer pays your pension fund. Very nice thank you!
goatty wrote:We DO pay our own pension. The government contribute to the pension in the same way that many private sector companies do for their employees. By the way, last week I worked over 60 hours- hardly any of it was marking.
High Treason wrote:boo hoo. Poor hard done by soul!
Pablo23 wrote:You talk some utter rubbish.
I wish I had as much time off work as teachers do.
The teacher I know does a 50 hour week which includes marking papers and preparation during evenings and weekends. School trips, often away for several days and has the responsibility of the pupils for 24 hours a day. No extra pay as with parents evenings, department meetings etc. In reality most of those posting negative comments do not have the intelligence, patience and dedication to be a teacher.
Try living in the real world. 4 weeks paid holiday instead of 13 to start with. Also state paid pension thank you very much!
50 hours a week- yeah right. We can all say we were doing marking work at home!
Most are lazy and over paid, both with wages and benefits. They should pay their own **** pension and enjoy the same amount of paid holidays as we all do.
Also you fail to address the 13 weeks holiday, whereas most people enjoy only 4 weeks or 5 if they are lucky!
Also why after weeks and weeks off in the Summer do you need to take a Teachers Training day off the first day of term???
I cannot find any reports of teachers being made redundant or sack for incompetence. Wonder why that is??? Job for life maybe!
I wonder how long teachers would last in the real world...No pay rise, No Government paid pension, 4 weeks holiday, having to go to work when it snows and no chance of being made redundant?
Finally, strange that teachers don't want to shout out that they are redundant or sacked due to incompetence. You would think they would want to announce it on the front page! Do a search for 'Purbeck teachers redundant'. Then please stop talking rubbish!
It amazes me people make career choices then moan about it later. In all jobs there are things we dont like. I hate it when a client calls me on the weekend (when I am not being paid) but I love my job overall and i have to take the rough with the smooth....
The funny thing is, if teachers want a rise, then you need less people going into the teaching profession. The government will then have to raise the salary bands to attract the staff. Simple rules of demand and supply. Sadly, the quality of teaching is slipping. IN MY OPINION I reckon this is more because class discipline is too restricitve, too much PC/non-PC laws and pointless paperwork.
I was taught by some great teachers WITHOUT an assistant and maintained total control over 30 kids of all backgrounds and behaviour-some of which was bad. Not sure why this has changed?
So I think the teaching profession has evolved and parents should realise that their little angels are not always co-operative.
That said, I could not and would not teach simply because i dont like the conditions, i dont have the patience and dont like the pay hence, I vote with my feet and I am in a profession I enjoy and do. But teachers cannot argue and say they are hard done by....no, we all are.
Trade Unions really need to think carefully as does the government as it is the teacher that seems to carry the brunt
chrisii1991 says...
1:00pm Thu 21 Mar 13