News RSS Feed


Costa Concordia terror: ‘Men pushed to get to rafts’

The sinking liner off the Italian coast The sinking liner off the Italian coast

A RETIRED policeman who escaped the stricken liner Concordia says panicking male passengers pushed in front of women to get into lifeboats.

Edwin Gurd, 64, from Burley, said he was shocked as he watched the men force their way onto the boats.

The former chief inspector, who was aboard with his wife Liz, 58, also revealed how some passengers held up the evacuation by taking photos and video footage on their mobile phones as they clambered into life rafts.

Mr Gurd says the first lifeboats started to be lowered about half an hour after the ship first “juddered” when it smashed into a rock off the coast of Tuscany in Italy.

At first women and children boarded the lifeboats in an orderly manner, but as the ship started to list badly a number of male passengers started to panic and push towards the life rafts.

Mr Gurd said: “I couldn’t believe there were some idiots taking photos with their mobile phones, actually hindering people as they got into lifeboats.

“I expect they were looking to get their shots on U-Tube. Fair enough when you are safe and sound on land, but to try and take pictures while people are attempting to get into lifeboats was ridiculous.

“The men were stressing and panicking. They were pushing past women who should have got on first.”

Mr Gurd and his wife were in their cabin at 9.30pm when the ship hit the rocks.

“We heard this loud juddering and all the lights went out. We decided to head three decks up to our lifeboat muster station and as we left a staff member told us it could just be the generator had packed up,” said Mr Gurd.

Mr Gurd described how from the start he and his wife “had a feeling that something was not right” so the couple took their documents and lifejackets to the lifeboat station.

Despite passing crew members telling passengers “there was nothing to worry about” and urging people to return to cabins, the couple continued to the muster station because the ship was listing slightly.

“I looked out from the ship and saw the cliffs on the shore. They were only 50 metres away and I thought ‘what are they doing so close?’ The former policeman said the crew seemed to have problems lowering many of the lifeboats, particularly as the ship started to list dangerously.

“My wife got onto lifeboat 17, she was practically the last one on and I was told there was no more room, so I moved on.

“There was a lot of panic from the male passengers. I thought there was a real threat of crush injuries because of their actions.

“They were pushing past women to get to the lifeboats. I was very disappointed in their behaviour.

He said crew members acted “brilliantly.”

As Mr Gurd waited to board an inflatable lifeboat, the list had become so dangerous he was struggling to stand up.”

It was nearly an hour after Mr Gurd’s wife had escaped the sinking liner when finally one of the lifeboats, which had already taken passengers to shore, returned and he was able to board that.

Mr Gurd and his wife were reunited after arranging a rendezvous at the quayside by ringing home and speaking to their daughter Brenda.

The couple, who flew home from Nice last night, had paid £900 each to go on the week-long cruise.

Mr Gurd said: “We are happy to be alive, but I don’t think my wife will be wanting to go on another cruise again in a hurry.”

Comments(7)

SandstormUK says...
8:35am Tue 17 Jan 12

What the heck is "U-Tube"? It's the third most visited website on the net and The Echo doesn't expect it's journalists to know what it's called? Or is freestyle spelling acceptable journalistic practice these days?

Gordon Clifton says...
11:29am Tue 17 Jan 12

Mr Gurd says that women should have been allowed to get on the liferafts first. Not these days. This is a result of the relentless march of the feministas and their aim of superiority, not equality. Just as men no longer give up their seats on public transport for women, or open doors for them, they will not give women priority in the queue for liferafts. Why should they?

Women have clamoured for equality; they have benefited from bias in education; they can go to war and so on. They cannot expect special treatment. Men who have been marginalised for at least 20 years will be in no mood to make unwarranted concessions. Like it or not, this is the new world.

H2o-hara says...
5:00pm Tue 17 Jan 12

Something tells me that they were probably not British .

static kill says...
8:33pm Tue 17 Jan 12

H2o-hara wrote:
Something tells me that they were probably not British .
Actually, something tells me they probably were :/

WHITEDOM says...
12:49pm Wed 18 Jan 12

Gordon Clifton wrote:
Mr Gurd says that women should have been allowed to get on the liferafts first. Not these days. This is a result of the relentless march of the feministas and their aim of superiority, not equality. Just as men no longer give up their seats on public transport for women, or open doors for them, they will not give women priority in the queue for liferafts. Why should they? Women have clamoured for equality; they have benefited from bias in education; they can go to war and so on. They cannot expect special treatment. Men who have been marginalised for at least 20 years will be in no mood to make unwarranted concessions. Like it or not, this is the new world.
Thank you Gordon Clifton. This is the most correct comment I have read on this site for a long while.

There is absolutely nothing wrong whatsoever with what you have said.

I for one would not have been giving my place up on a life raft for any particular type of person, that's for sure. Not in this day and age. Why would I sacrifice myself for a possible drug using mother or rioting teenager? I am more use to the world than they are.

Everyone for themselves is the best strategy in such a situation - it worked as well. For such an event it is no miracle that so few people were killed. Common sense and selfishness doubtless saved scores of people.

throatwarbler says...
1:18pm Wed 18 Jan 12

"For such an event it is no miracle that so few people were killed. Common sense and selfishness doubtless saved scores of people."

Too true. So did the captain by making sure they crashed into rocks close enough to the Island to help make the rescue easier.

bornINpoole69 says...
4:07pm Wed 18 Jan 12

throatwarbler wrote:
"For such an event it is no miracle that so few people were killed. Common sense and selfishness doubtless saved scores of people." Too true. So did the captain by making sure they crashed into rocks close enough to the Island to help make the rescue easier.
if the captain did not take the ship off course in the first place then it would not have neede to crash into anything!
stupit idiota capitano

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree